Replacement lowers concentration: A jar of whisky is 40% alcohol. A portion is removed and replaced with another whisky that is 19% alcohol, resulting in a final alcohol percentage of 26%. What fraction of the original whisky was replaced?
-
A1/3
-
B2/5
-
C2/3
-
D3/5
-
E1/2
Answer
Correct Answer: 2/3
Explanation
Introduction / Context: In replacement problems, concentrations combine linearly. If a fraction r of volume is replaced, the final concentration equals the remaining part of the old concentration plus the added part of the new concentration. Volumes cancel, leaving an equation in r only.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Initial alcohol fraction = 0.40.
- Replacing fraction = r (of the total volume).
- Incoming alcohol fraction = 0.19.
- Final fraction = 0.26.
Concept / Approach: Final fraction = (1 − r)*0.40 + r*0.19. Solve for r to find the portion replaced.
Step-by-Step Solution:
(1 − r)*0.40 + r*0.19 = 0.260.40 − 0.40r + 0.19r = 0.260.40 − 0.21r = 0.26 ⇒ 0.21r = 0.14 ⇒ r = 2/3Verification / Alternative check: Substitute r = 2/3: final = (1/3)*0.40 + (2/3)*0.19 = 0.1333… + 0.1266… ≈ 0.26, matching the target.
Why Other Options Are Wrong: Other fractions produce final concentrations different from 26%; only 2/3 balances the convex combination between 40% and 19%.
Common Pitfalls: Averaging 40% and 19% without weighting by r and (1 − r); ignoring that only a fraction of the original remains.
Final Answer: 2/3