Blocks of identical copies kept together: A library has two books each with three identical copies, and three other books each with two identical copies. In how many ways can all these books be arranged on a shelf so that copies of the same book are not separated (i.e., kept together)?
-
A120
-
B180
-
C160
-
D140
Answer
Correct Answer: 120
Explanation
Introduction / Context:We have five distinct titles with multiple identical copies per title: two titles have 3 copies each, three titles have 2 copies each. Since identical copies within a title are indistinguishable and must be kept together, each title forms a single block on the shelf.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Titles: A, B with 3 identical copies each; C, D, E with 2 identical copies each.
- “Not separated” means all copies of a title appear contiguously, acting as one block.
- Identical copies ⇒ internal permutations within a block do not create new arrangements.
Concept / Approach:Treat each title as one block. Then we simply arrange 5 distinct blocks on the shelf.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Number of blocks = 5Arrangements of 5 distinct blocks = 5! = 120No internal multiplicative factor: copies per block are identical, not distinct.Verification / Alternative check:Alternative reasoning confirms that any reordering within a block of identical copies is not distinguishable and thus does not increase the count.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:180, 160, 140 imply extra (nonexistent) internal permutations or incorrect block counts.
Common Pitfalls:Treating identical copies as distinct (which would erroneously multiply the count).
Final Answer:120