Systems analysis and evaluation: When comparing alternatives during system design, the “best” alternative is recognized as the one that most effectively does which of the following?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: best enabling the system to meet its objectives

Explanation:

Introduction / Context:Systems analysis requires evaluating alternatives against clear objectives. While cost and pros/cons matter, the primary criterion is alignment with the defined system goals—functionality, performance, compliance, and value. This question asks you to select the essence of “best.”

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Objectives are defined in the requirements and business case.
  • Trade-offs include cost, schedule, risk, quality, and scope.
  • We seek the overarching decision principle.

Concept / Approach:The best alternative maximizes goal satisfaction for the stakeholders, within constraints. Lowest cost alone may underdeliver; tallying advantages/disadvantages without reference to objectives can mislead. Therefore, the alternative that best enables the system to meet its objectives is preferred, subject to constraints and feasibility.

Step-by-Step Solution:

Start from the problem statement and success criteria.Evaluate each option against the criteria (fit, performance, risk, compliance).Select the alternative with the highest objective attainment, not just lowest cost.

Verification / Alternative check:Decision-analysis methods (weighted scoring, utility functions, cost-benefit with value measures) formalize this principle: maximize value against stated objectives.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:

representing lowest cost: can sacrifice mission-critical outcomes.with the most advantages / least disadvantages: counts without weighting by objectives can be misleading.None of the above: incorrect because option (a) reflects the core principle.

Common Pitfalls:Optimizing for a single metric (cost or time) while violating constraints like security or compliance.

Final Answer: best enabling the system to meet its objectives

More Questions from Management Information Systems

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion