Clock geometry — Between 9 o’clock and 10 o’clock, at what exact time are the hands of a clock in the same straight line but not together (i.e., opposite at 180 degrees)?
-
A9 :164/11
-
B9 :154/11
-
C9 :174/11
-
DNone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: None of these
Explanation
Introduction / Context:“Straight line but not together” means the hands are opposite (180 degrees apart). We seek the time after 9 o’clock when this occurs.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- At 9:00, hour angle = 270°, minute angle = 0°.
- Let t be minutes after 9:00.
- Hour angle = 270 + 0.5t; minute angle = 6t.
Concept / Approach:Solve |6t − (270 + 0.5t)| = 180 for t in (0, 60).
Step-by-Step Solution:5.5t = 450 → t = 900/11 ≈ 81.818 (invalid for this hour).5.5t = 90 → t = 180/11 ≈ 16.364 (valid).Thus time = 9 : 180/11.
Verification / Alternative check:Substituting t = 180/11 gives a 180° separation exactly.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:164/11, 154/11, 174/11 minutes do not satisfy the 180° condition.
Common Pitfalls:Choosing the extraneous solution (>60 min) or rounding fractions.
Final Answer:9 : 180/11 (not listed), therefore “None of these.”