Two workers with a helper: Ramesh and Suresh take a job for ₹ 800. Ramesh alone can finish it in 12 days; Suresh alone in 16 days. With the assistance of a boy, they finish in 6 days. How should the money be divided among Ramesh, Suresh, and the boy, proportional to work done?
-
ARamesh = ₹ 100, Suresh = ₹ 300 and boy = ₹ 400
-
BRamesh = ₹ 200, Suresh = ₹ 200 and boy = ₹ 400
-
CRamesh = ₹ 400, Suresh = ₹ 300 and boy = ₹ 100
-
DRamesh = ₹ 300, Suresh = ₹ 400 and boy = ₹ 100
-
ENone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: Ramesh = ₹ 400, Suresh = ₹ 300 and boy = ₹ 100
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Lump-sum wage splitting by contribution requires computing each person's share of the total work. The boy's presence speeds up completion to 6 days; from this we infer his effective rate and then split ₹ 800 accordingly.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Rate(Ramesh) = 1/12
- Rate(Suresh) = 1/16
- Total rate with boy = 1/6
- Total amount = ₹ 800
Concept / Approach:Boy's rate = total rate − (Ramesh + Suresh) rate. Then, each share fraction = rate / total rate. Multiply these fractions by ₹ 800 to determine the payments.
Step-by-Step Solution:Rate(R+S) = 1/12 + 1/16 = 4/48 + 3/48 = 7/48Total rate = 1/6 = 8/48Rate(boy) = 8/48 − 7/48 = 1/48Share fractions (multiply by 6): R = 6*(1/12) = 1/2; S = 6*(1/16) = 3/8; Boy = 6*(1/48) = 1/8Payments: R = 1/2*800 = ₹ 400; S = 3/8*800 = ₹ 300; Boy = 1/8*800 = ₹ 100
Verification / Alternative check:Fractions sum to 1; payments sum to ₹ 800 — consistent.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:Options that give the boy ₹ 400 or ₹ 100 but mis-allocate others do not match the exact rate-derived fractions.
Common Pitfalls:Proportioning by days worked instead of rates; miscomputing the boy's rate by forgetting to subtract both Ramesh and Suresh from the total rate.
Final Answer:Ramesh = ₹ 400, Suresh = ₹ 300 and boy = ₹ 100