A cask contains 25 liters of wine. First 5 liters are withdrawn and replaced by water; this is repeated twice more (three operations in total). Find the quantity of wine left and the ratio of wine to water in the final mixture.
-
A61 : 64
-
B16 : 46
-
C46 : 16
-
D64 : 61
-
E1 : 1
Answer
Correct Answer: 64 : 61
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Repeated replacement problems use the exponential decay formula for the retained fraction after each withdrawal. Each time 5 liters are removed from 25 liters, the same fraction of wine is taken out and replaced by water.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Initial wine = 25 L.
- Each operation: remove 5 L, then add 5 L water.
- Number of operations = 3.
Concept / Approach:After each operation, the fraction of wine remaining equals (1 − 5/25) = 4/5 of the previous amount. After n operations: wine_left = 25*(4/5)^n.
Step-by-Step Solution:wine_left = 25*(4/5)^3 = 25*(64/125) = 12.8 LWater = total − wine = 25 − 12.8 = 12.2 LWine : Water = 12.8 : 12.2 = 128 : 122 = 64 : 61
Verification / Alternative check:Successive amounts: after 1st = 20 L, 2nd = 16 L, 3rd = 12.8 L; consistent with (4/5)^n scaling.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:46 : 16 reverses values; 61 : 64 is water : wine, not wine : water; 1 : 1 is inaccurate.
Common Pitfalls:Subtracting 5 liters of wine each time (linear) instead of multiplying by 4/5 (geometric).
Final Answer:64 : 61